1. The Fundamental Legal Differences
English land law separates the **legal title** from the **beneficial interest (equity)**:
• **The Legal Title:** Under Section 34 of the Law of Property Act 1925, the legal title can *only* ever be held as Joint Tenants (by a maximum of four trustees). The legal owners are the names on the deeds responsible for mortgage payments and signing sale documents.
• **The Beneficial Interest:** This is where the financial equity sits. Co-owners must elect on HM Land Registry Transfer Form TR1 (Panel 10) whether they hold the equity as Joint Tenants or Tenants in Common.
| Feature | Joint Tenants | Tenants in Common |
|---|---|---|
| Equity Split | Equal 100% undivided interest | Divided into specific shares (e.g. 60/40, 75/25, or deposit-first) |
| What Happens on Death? | Right of Survivorship: passes automatically to surviving co-owner | Passes according to the deceased co-owner's Will or Intestacy Rules |
| Can it be bequeathed in a Will? | NO — Wills cannot override the Right of Survivorship | YES — Full testamentary freedom to leave share to anyone |
| Unequal Deposit Protection | IMPOSSIBLE — Proceeds are split 50/50 upon separation | PROTECTED — Backed by a formal Declaration of Trust |
| Land Registry Entry | Standard Title Register entry | Form A Restriction entered on the Proprietorship Register |
2. The Unequal Deposit Dilemma: Why You Need a Deed of Trust
Over 60% of modern UK joint purchases involve unequal initial deposits (e.g. Partner A contributes £60,000 from personal savings or an inheritance, while Partner B contributes £10,000).
If the couple buys as standard **Joint Tenants** and subsequently separates after 3 years, the law presumes equal ownership (*Stack v Dowden [2007]*). In the absence of a written trust, the equity from a sale is split 50/50, causing Partner A to lose £25,000 of their initial deposit.
Under **Tenants in Common**, conveyancing solicitors draft a **Declaration of Trust (Deed of Trust)** specifying that upon sale:
1. Partner A first receives their £60,000 deposit back.
2. Partner B first receives their £10,000 deposit back.
3. Any remaining net capital appreciation is divided 50/50.
Under Section 36(2) of the Law of Property Act 1925, either co-owner has the unilateral right to 'sever' a Joint Tenancy and convert it into a Tenancy in Common without the other party's agreement, simply by serving a formal written Notice of Severance and filing Form SEV with HM Land Registry.
3. Form A Restriction & Land Registry Registration
When you select Tenants in Common, HM Land Registry automatically enters a **Form A Restriction** on the Proprietorship Register of Title:
• *'No disposition by a sole proprietor of the registered estate... under which capital money arises is to be registered unless authorized by an order of the court.'*
This restriction guarantees that if one co-owner dies or attempts to sell the property behind the other's back, a sole surviving owner cannot sell the property or pocket the mortgage proceeds without appointing a second trustee to protect the deceased's beneficial share.