1. Common Equity Formulas Used in Deeds of Trust
When drafting a Declaration of Trust, co-owners must choose one of three mathematical structures to govern a future property sale:
• **Formula A: Fixed Deposit Return First (Most Popular):** Each party receives their exact initial deposit sum back upon sale (£50k and £10k). All remaining net profit or equity growth is then split 50/50.
• **Formula B: Floating Percentage Share:** Equity is calculated as a percentage reflecting both the deposit and ongoing mortgage contribution (e.g. Partner A owns 65%, Partner B owns 35% of the total property value at any given moment).
• **Formula C: Deposit Return with Capital Appreciation Proportion:** Each party gets their initial deposit back plus an exact proportional share of property price inflation reflecting their initial contribution.
| Distribution Formula | How Sale Proceeds Are Split | Best Suited For |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed Deposit First | Deposits returned in full first; remaining equity split 50/50 | Couples paying unequal deposits but sharing mortgage equally |
| Fixed Percentage (e.g. 70/30) | Entire net sale proceeds split by agreed fixed percentage | One partner paying larger deposit AND larger mortgage share |
| Loan Agreement (Gifted Trust) | Deposit treated as an interest-free loan repaid upon sale | Bank of Mum and Dad funds that must be returned to parents |
2. The Landmark Legal Risk: Stack v Dowden (2007)
The leading House of Lords case on cohabitation property disputes is *Stack v Dowden [2007] UKHL 17*.
In that case, the court ruled that where a domestic property is purchased in joint names without an express declaration of trust, **the starting presumption is that the beneficial equity is owned equally (50/50)**.
Rebutting this presumption requires protracted, expensive litigation in the High Court under the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996 (TOLATA), with legal fees regularly exceeding £30,000 to £50,000.
A properly executed £400 Deed of Trust eliminates all ambiguity and prevents court litigation entirely.
All parties named on the mortgage must also be named on the legal title. Mortgage lenders strictly require both borrowers to be jointly and severally liable for 100% of the mortgage debt, regardless of what internal equity percentages are agreed in your Deed of Trust.
3. Step-by-Step Execution Checklist
To put a Deed of Trust in place during your property purchase:
1. **Inform Your Conveyancer Early:** Notify your solicitor before mortgage valuation so the deed can be prepared alongside the contract pack.
2. **Agree the Buyout Mechanism:** Include a pre-emption clause specifying that if one party wants to sell, the other partner has a 30-to-60-day window to buy out their share at independent RICS market valuation.
3. **Register at HM Land Registry:** Ensure the conveyancer enters a Form A Restriction on the Title Register to protect the deed against third parties.